Can a Subsequent Amendment Impair the Vested Right of Appeal?

I am sharing all six parts of my six-part series together, for the convenience of readers who may wish to read the series in its entirety.

Advertisements

What began as an examination of the impact of the Finance Act, 2025 amendments on the right of appeal gradually evolved into a much wider jurisprudential journey — through the doctrine of vested appellate rights, the commencement of the lis, the effect of subsequent amendments, and the continuing relevance of the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in Hoosein Kasam Dada and Garikapati Veeraya.

The series also brought me back to a fundamental distinction which, in my respectful view, lies at the heart of the controversy: the distinction between the power to amend the law and the intention to impair retrospectively a right which had already vested.

Penning this six-part series has been a particularly enriching and satisfying experience for me. It has involved considerable reading, revisiting some foundational authorities, examining seemingly divergent decisions in their respective statutory contexts, and, above all, reflecting on a principle which has remained remarkably constant despite the changing statutory landscape.

I am grateful to the entire TIOL team for their continued support, encouragement and for providing such a valuable platform for professional discourse.

I hope readers will find the complete series useful and, as always, I look forward to their observations and feedback.

Regards,
Shailesh Sheth
Advocate

Share this content:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *