P&H HC: Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab

The recent judgment of the Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab (CWP-34296-2024 and 423 connected petitions, pronounced on 01.10.2026) runs to 104 pages. Reading it in full is laborious, but for anyone practising GST law it is essential work.

Advertisements

Being of the old school, I read the entire judgment with a highlighting pen in hand. Many of its observations kindle real interest, swinging at times in favour of the provision and at times against it. Just as the reader begins to anticipate a particular outcome, there is a sudden turn.

A few of those turns:

▪ The Hon’ble Court accepts that the matching machinery of Sections 41 to 43 was never implemented, and invokes the maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia (para 75).
▪ It holds that Section 76, the remedy against the supplier who collects tax but does not pay it, cannot be rendered otiose by routine invocation of Section 16(2)(c) against the purchaser (para 82).
▪ It observes that the incidence of tax ought not to be shifted to a purchaser who has already paid tax to the seller (para 86).
▪ Yet, out of judicial discipline in the light of Maruti Enterprises and Bhandari Scrap Traders, the vires of Section 16(2)(c) is upheld and the provision is not read down (para 98).
▪ Fourteen guidelines are then laid down to govern its invocation (para 103), and the petitions are disposed of with directions for fresh adjudication (para 105).

The judgment is, in every sense, an excellent one. In my humble opinion, however, it may not fully meet the expectations of the taxpayer, despite the many favourable observations made in his support.
Hence this article, “Twists and Turns”. For the reader’s convenience:
▪ The relevant paragraphs are extracted verbatim, so that the text of the Hon’ble Court can be read alongside the comment.

▪ The directions in para 105 are compared with the CBIC Press Release of 04.05.2018, Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST and the Master Circular on adjudication.
▪ The guidelines are compared with State instructions on the principles of natural justice and the issuance of speaking orders, taking the Tamil Nadu Circulars No. 12/2022 and No. 8/2024 as an illustration.

The article is shared purely for enjoying the twists and turns, and for whatever else a reader may find useful in it. It is written with the deepest respect to the Hon’ble Bench and is intended only for academic discussion.

Your views, comments and differing perspectives are most welcome.
B Venkateswaran

Share this content:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *